Masculinities Mondays: 16th of March 2015


Photo: Mohammad Ismail/Reuters

From dancing in Dili to cross-dressing in Kabul, millions of women and men, girls and boys, around the world spent last week celebrating International Women’s Day, joining forces to honour women’s contributions and to heighten awareness of the many injustices and challenges that women across the globe still face. This week, those conversations about masculinities and gender equality continue, in various forms:

  • The 59th Commission on the Status of Women is currently underway in New York. But if you thought this was only about women and for women, you’re mistaken. If you’re in the Big Apple, there are some great CSO side events on masculinities. Check them out here and here – just don’t forget to RSVP!
  • An article has recently been published examining men’s lifetime physical intimate partner violence (IPV) perpetration across eight low- and middle-income countries to better understand key risk factors that interventions can target in order to promote gender equality and reduce IPV. In exploring data from men in Bosnia and Herzegovina, Brazil, Chile, Croatia, Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC), India, Mexico, and Rwanda, the authors found that witnessing parental violence was the strongest risk factor for men’s perpetration of physical violence against a partner. Having been involved in fights not specifically with an intimate partner, permissive attitudes towards violence against women, having inequitable gender attitudes, and older age were all also associated with a higher likelihood of ever perpetrating physical IPV.
  • In Denmark, a professor is controversially campaigning to have pornography shown in sex educational classes in all schools. Prof Christian Graugaard states,

My proposal is to critically discuss pornography with 8th and 9th graders [age 15 – the legal age of consent in Denmark – and 16 respectively] as part of a sensible didactic strategy, carried out by trained teachers…We know from research that a vast majority of teenagers have seen porn at an early age – so it’s not a question of introducing youngsters to porn…We should strengthen their ability to distinguish between the media’s depictions of the body and sex and the everyday life of an average teenager. They should become conscientious and critical consumers.

  • And, while we are on the topic of sex education, if you read anything this week, make it this brilliant article that explains how sexual consent is really as simple as a cup of tea.
  • To wrap up, we’d like to leave you with a video from Indonesia on transforming masculinities for positive social change, brought to you by MenCare+ and Rutgers WPF.

Have a great, active and transformative week!

International Women’s Day around the world

Some interesting stories about gender equality are coming out in the news right now, for International Women’s Day on March 8th, so if you’re wondering what’s the point of celebrating this day, have a look:

  • While China continues its, albeit slowed, economic boom, Didi Kristin Tatlow and Michael Forsythe’s recent article in the New York Times explains how Chinese women are being left out of the opportunities for financial gain and career development. Less than one in 10 board members of China’s top 300 companies are women and, in terms of government, no woman has ever been on the Politburo Standing Committee. Feminist, Feng Yuan describes,

We call it the ‘sticky floor. There is a glass ceiling here too, but most women never even get off the sticky floor.

Read the full story here.

  • The Chinese police then marked International Women’s Day by detaining at least 10 women’s rights activists, who had been trying to organise a nation-wide campaign on ending sexual harassment in public transportation. A lawyer representing one of the activists remarked,

We’ve always thought the country supports equal rights for women. Speaking as a lawyer, this act is beyond our imagination and has shocked us.

Obviously they’ve just broken down the last barrier and they’ve made the men-only club admit women…Admit women! Isn’t that fantastic? At last, this bastion of chauvinism has admitted women and they’ve done it on International Women’s Day because of the Liberal National Party.

Mr Abbott failed to add that the club will continue to not allow women to become members after the event.

  • In Southern Africa, the Salvation Army came up with a very effective way to use a recent social media craze to raise awareness about violence against women. Tapping into the recent online sensation of a dress that appeared to some people to be black and blue and to others as white and gold, the Salvation Army produced the strong campaign below. The image reads “Why is it so hard to see black and blue. The only illusion is if you think it was her choice. One in 6 women are victims of abuse. Stop abuse against women”Salvation Army dress
  • The Asian Development Bank has released an infographic of wage inequality in Asia and the Pacific. According to the ADB data, women in the region earn between 70-90% of what men earn for the same work!
  • And, in India, Priya – a new, female hero – has been named a UN Women Gender Equality Champion as she continues to spread awareness about preventing violence against women and promoting gender equality – all on the back of a tiger! stand_with_priya3-1024x1019
  • The 59th session of the Commission on the Status of Women kicked off today and will run until the 20th of March. The theme this year is on implementing the Beijing Platform for Action.
  • We know there are a lot of parts of the world not listed here. And that’s so that YOU can tell us how YOU (or your friends/community/country have been celebrating IWD. In the meantime, stay tuned for regular updates of the IWD buzz this week.

Masculinities Mondays: 16th of February 2015

DocLibJust in time to celebrate V-Day and join the worldwide One Billion Rising movement to raise awareness about violence against women, the EMERGE Project (Engendering Men: Evidence on Routes to Gender Equality) has released a new resource that gathers evidence and lessons on what works in engaging men and boys for gender equality. The EMERGE Document Library consolidates recent datasets, books, articles and programme reports along nine priority themes:

It still seems to be a fledgling site but we look forward to it becoming more populated with excellent resources from around the world. If you’ve got something to add, let them know.

Happy reading!

Masculinities Mondays: 9th of February 2015

Just a week after a PSA on domestic violence was aired during the Super Bowl, today we want to give a big shout out to Obama for his inspiring PSA, delivered during the Grammy Awards. Highlighting the role that everyone has to play in preventing violence, the President said,

We can change our culture for the better by ending violence against women and girls…It’s not okay and it has to stop…All of us, in our own lives, have the power to set an example…It’s on us – all of us – to create a culture where violence isn’t tolerated; where survivors are supported; and where all our young people – men and women – can go as far as their talents and their dreams will take them.

There is a long history of popular music on the theme of violence against women – both condemning it and condoning it – and, just last year, a Colombian campaign used images to bring attention to the extreme violence against women in reggaeton lyrics (See the campaign here. Warning: graphic images).

But having the President of the United States call up everyone on their responsibility to end violence against women and girls, is something definitely worth celebrating – especially when his opponents are busy doing this.

See the whole video here: 

Homosexuality and Aboriginal Culture

Although it’s from a few months ago, we’ve just come across this brilliant article by Steven Lindsay Ross about being gay and Indigenous in Australia.

He writes,

We were also lucky enough to have Elder LGBTI people guide us through our childhood and coming-out phases. Small country towns are not the most hospitable places for young black kids, let alone young black LGBTI kids…Aboriginal people have been in Australia for more than 60,000 years in what many anthropologists describe as a triumph of survival and mathematics. Given the overwhelming evidence that homosexuality is biological, it is logical to assume that homosexuality would have been a part of such a social equation. It is estimated that there have been four billion Aboriginal people In Australia since the dawn of time. Four billion, and not one gay person? That just defies belief.

Read the whole article here and also check out the work of Black Rainbow, which intends to start the first mental health service for Indigenous LGBTI Australians.

Masculinities Mondays: 2nd of February 2015

Even for those of us not from or living in the States, it is hard to avoid at least some exposure to the Super Bowl, which – this Sunday – was watched by over 114 million viewers. Due to the massive exposure, the ads shown during the Super Bowl cost companies $9 million per minute and receive almost as much commentary as the game itself. This year, however, observers noticed some different trends and themes away from the tradition of ads targeted at hegemonic masculinity.

Firstly, this year’s Super Bowl ads featured a public service announcement about domestic violence, from the organisation No More. As Caitlin Kelly of The New Yorker explains, this comes in on the heels of a year during which violence against women and exploitation were recurring issues in the news for the National Football League (NFL).  Based on true stories of calls received to emergency services, the video depicts a woman’s phone call to 911 in which she pretends to be ordering a pizza so as not to alert the perpetrator that she is calling the police. The ad concludes with the message, “When it’s hard to talk, it’s up to us to listen.” While it’s good that such an important issue was able to receive so much coverage through a 30-second slot, the messaging is a little unclear. Is the “us” who will listen to NFL? Or the police? Or bystanders? And what, precisely, is the call to action after listening? And will this really be followed through with the implementation of more rigorous policies on violence against women within national sports leagues in the U.S.? For the latter, at least, time will most certainly tell.

In addition to raising awareness about domestic violence, however, this year’s ads also promoted ways of being a man that emphasise and value caring. An ad for men’s skin care products, for example, showed men as responsible and loving fathers and culminates in the tagline “Care makes a man stronger.”  Another, for a car, depicts a father reminiscing about his daughter’s childhood as he drives her to the airport to join the army – a choice, we are told, was her own.

Of course, as Ana Swanson points out, at the end of the day these commercials – the PSA aside – are really just trying to make more money by convincing people to buy more. Yet, the fact that these companies have decided that the way they will make more money is by reaching out to a more nuanced form of masculinity, predicated on nurturing, loving and showing emotion (and spending millions of dollars on this message), may signify a broader cultural shift. And it’s a shift that we, for one, are looking forward to.